Essential Films Noir

carrefour Essential Films Noir

FilmsNoir.Net’s list of the 229 essential films noir. The list is in two parts:

  1. The 71 all-time great films noir – rated 5-stars
  2. The 160  runners-up – rated 4 or 4.5 stars

The list is not definitive. There are gaps. Missing are neo-noirs, a few French noirs, and directors such as Hitchcock. There are varied reasons but mostly the gaps are due to my personal predictions, or because some films are not fresh enough in my mind and need to be watched again with their candidacy here in mind.

5 star Noirs Click on the title for the FilmsNoir.Net review

La Nuit du Carrefour

1931

France

Aka ‘Night at the Crossroads’. Early Jean Renoir poetics. Magically delicious femme-noir and a brilliant car chase at night. Moody and bizarrre!

You Only Live Once

1937

US

Fritz Lang and Hollywood kick-start poetic realism! Henry Fonda and Sylvia Sidney are the doomed lovers on the run.

Hotel du Nord

1938

France

Poetic realist melodrama of lives at provincial French hotel. As moody as noir with a darkly absurd resolution.

Port of Shadows

1938

France

Aka Le Quai des brumes. Fate a dank existential fog ensnares doomed lovers Jean Gabin and Michèle Morgan after one night of happiness.

I Wake Up Screaming

1941

US

Early crooked cop psycho-noir. Redolent noir motifs, dark shadows, off-kilter framing and expressionist imagery.

The Maltese Falcon

1941

US

Bogart as Sam Spade the quintessential noir protagonist. A loner on the edge of polite society, sorely tempted to transgress but declines and is neither saved nor redeemed.

Ossessione

1942

Italy

Demands and rewards multiple viewings. Visconti has taken a hard-boiled story and imbued it with intelligence, polemic, a humanist outrage, and above all, a deep compassion for the human predicament.

Journey Into Fear

1943

US

Moody Orson Welles’ noir. Exotic locales, sexy dames, weird villains, politics, wisdom, philosophy, and a wry humor.

The Seventh Victim

1943

US

“Despair behind, and death before doth cast”. The terror of an empty existence. Brilliant Lewton gothic melodrama.

Christmas Holiday

1944

US

Director Robert Siodmak smashes genre conventions by unleashing a wild expressionist ambience in a bizarre story of obsession and guilt that

has you appalled yet enthralled. Full of bizarre surprises.

Double Indemnity

1944

US

All the elements of the archetypal film noir  are distilled into a gothic LA tale of greed, sex, and betrayal.

Laura

1944

US

Gene Tierney is an exquisite iridescent angel and Dana Andrews a stolid cop who nails the killer after falling for a dead dame.

Murder, My Sweet

1944

US

(Aka Farewell, my Lovely). The most noir fun you will ever have. Raymond Chandler’s prose crackles with moody noir direction from Edward Dmytryk.

The Way You Wanted Me

1944

Finland

“Sellaisena kuin sinä minut halusit” (original title). A dark frenzied tale of a fallen woman, The Way You Wanted Me careens across roads of melodrama at the speed of light. Hyper-expressionism and a tragedy played out in dark nights of the soul.

Mildred Pierce

1945

US

Joan Crawford in classy melodrama by Michael Curtiz lensed by Ernest Haller. Self-made woman escapes morass of greed.

The Lost Weekend

1945

US

‘Most men lead lives of quiet desperation. I can’t take quiet desperation.’ Ray Milland against type on a bender.

Ride the Pink Horse

1946

US

Disillusioned WW2 vet arrives in a New Mexico town to blackmail a war racketeer. Imbued with a rare humanity.

Scarlet Street

1946

US

Classic noir from Fritz Lang. Unremitting in its pessimism. A dark mood and pervading doom of devastating intensity.

The Big Sleep

1946US Love’s Vengeance Lost. Darker than Dmytryk’s Murder, My Sweet. Bogart is tougher, more driven, and morally suspect.

The Killers

1946

US

Siodmak’s classic noir. Burt Lancaster’s masterful debut performance in a tragedy of a decent man destroyed by fate.

The Postman Always Rings Twice

1946

US

Fate ensures adulterous lovers who murder the woman’s husband, suffer definite and final retribution.

Body and Soul

1947

US

A masterwork. Melodramatic expose of the fight game and a savage indictment of money capitalism. Garfield’s picture.

Brighton Rock

1947

UK

Greatest British noir is dark and chilling. A cinematic tour-de-force: from the direction and cinematography to top cast and editing.

Nightmare Alley

1947

US

Predatory femme-fatale uses greed not sex to trap her prey in a hell of hangmen at the bottom of an empty gin bottle.

Nora Prentiss

1947

US

Doctor is plunged into a dark pool of noir angst in a turbo-charged melodrama of tortured loyalty and thwarted passion.

Odd Man Out

1947

UK

Betrayal, avarice, and spirituality are all given a place in this tale of an IRA heist gone wrong. The poetry is in the dark yet glistening visuals as we follow fugitive James Mason on his path through Ulster at night and in the rain.

Out of the Past

1947

US

Quintessential film noir. Inspired direction, exquisite expressionist cinematography, and legendary Mitchum and Greer.
The Gangster 1947

US

Hell of a b-movie. Very dark noir ‘opera’ brutally critiques the ‘entrepreneurial spirit’. Bravado Dalton Trumbo script.

The Lady From Shanghai

1947

US

Orson Welles’ brilliant jigsaw noir with a femme-fatale to die for and a script so sharp you relish every scene.

T-Men

1947

US

Mann and Alton offer a visionary descent into a noir realm of dark tenements, nightclubs, mobsters, and hellish steam baths.

Act of Violence

1948

US

Long-shot and deep focus climax filmed night-for-night on a railway platform: the stuff noirs are made of.

Drunken Angel 

1948

Japan

Aka ‘Yoidore tenshi’. Kurosawa noir. A loser doctor with soul takes on the fetid moral swamp of Yakuza degradation.

Force of Evil

1948

US

Polonsky transcends noir in a tragic allegory on greed and family. Garfield adds signature honesty and gritty complexity .

Hollow Triumph

1948

US

Baroque journey to perdition traversing a noir topography redolent with noir archetypes. Audacious and enthralling.

Raw Deal

1948

US

Sublime noir from Anthony Mann and John Alton. Knockout cast in a strong story stunningly rendered as expressionist art.

They Live by Night

1948

US

Nicholas Ray’s first feature. A tragedy of Shakespearean dimensions which transcends film noir.

Too Late For Tears

1948

US

Preposterous chance event launches wild descent into dark avarice and eroticised violence as relentless as fate.
Bitter Rice 1949

Italy

Aka ‘Riso Amaro’. Classic neo-realist socialist melodrama. Homme-fatale destroys a passionate innocent. A bad girl is redeemed and homme-fatale meets a gruesome noir end in an abattoir.

Border Incident

1949

US

Subversive expressionist noir from Dir Anthony Mann DP John Alton and writer John C Higgin indicts US agribusiness.

Criss-Cross

1949

US

Accomplished noir showcased by Siodmak’s masterful aerial opening shot into parking lot onto a passing car exposing the doomed lovers to the

spotlight.

Stray Dog

1949

Japan

Aka ‘Nora inu’. Kurosawa’s ying and yang take on reality informs this 5-star noir: the pursuer could as easily have been the pursued.

The Reckless Moment

1949

US

Max Ophuls takes a blackmail story and infuses it with a complexity and subtlety rarely matched in film noir.

The Set-Up

1949

US

Robert Ryan is great as washed-up boxer in Robert Wise’ sharp expose of the fight game. Brooding and intense noir classic.

The Third Man

1949

UK

Sublime. An engaging cavalcade of characters in a human comedy of love, friendship, and the imperatives of conscience.

Thieves’ Highway

1949

US

Moody Richard Conte hauling fruit to Frisco. Rich socio-realist melodrama from Jules Dassin and A.I. Bezzerides. AAA.

Une Si Jolie Petite Plage

1949

France

Aka ‘Riptide’. Iron in the soul: savage irony, withering subversion, and desolation mark the rain-sodden angst of a young man’s end.

White Heat

1949

US

Fission Noir. Taut electric thriller straps you in an emotional strait-jacket released only in the final explosive frames.

Breaking Point

1950

US

Great John Garfield vehicle with strong social subtext. Much stronger than from the same source To Have and Have Not.

Caged

1950

US

Eleanor Parker leads a great female cast in a dark women’s prison picture with a savage climax and a gutsy downbeat ending.

D.O.A.

1950

US

Gritty on-the-street in-your-face melodrama of innocent act a decent man’s un-doing. Edmund O’Brien is intense. The goons rock!

In A Lonely Place

1950

US

Nick Ray deftly explores effect of isolation, frustration, and anxiety on the creative psyche as noir entrapment.

Night And the City

1950

US/UK

Dassin’s stark existential journey played out in the dark dives of post-war London as a quintessential noir city.

Sunset Boulevard

1950

US

Wilder’s sympathetic story of four decent people each sadly complicit in the inevitable doom that will engulf them.

The Asphalt Jungle

1950

US

Quintessential heist movie transcends melodrama and noir. A police siren wails: “Sounds like a soul in hell.”

The Sound of Fury

1950

US

Great noir! Outdoes Lang’s Fury and brilliantly prefigures Wilder’s Ace in the Hole. Climactic mob scenes mesmerise.

On Dangerous Ground

1951

US

City cop battling inner demons is sent to ‘Siberia’. A film of dark beauty and haunting characterisations.

The Prowler

1951

US

Van Heflin is homme-fatale in Tumbo thriller. Director Losey is unforgiving. Each squalid act is suffocatingly framed.

Ace in the Hole

1952

US

A savage critique of a corrupted and corrupting modern mass media. Billy Wilder’s best movie. Kirk Douglas owns it.

Clash By Night

1952

US

Cheating wife Stanwyck faces the music. Fritz Lang puts sexual license and existential entitlement on trial and wins.

The Big Heat

1953

US

Gloria Grahame as existential hero in Fritz Lang’s brooding socio-realist noir critique.

Crime Wave

1954

US

Andre de Toth noir masterwork set on the streets of LA is so authentic it plays for real with each character deeply drawn.

Kiss Me Deadly

1955

US

Anti-fascist Hollywood Dada. Aldrich’s surreal noir a totally weird yet compelling exploration of urban paranoia.

Rififi

1955

France

Dassin’s classic heist thriller culminating in the terrific final scenes of a car desperately careening through Paris streets.

The Big Combo

1955

US

“I live in a maze… a strange blind backward maze’. Obsessed cop hunts down a psychotic crime boss in the best noir of 50s.

Sweet Smell of Success

1957

US

DP James Wong Howe’s sharpest picture. As bracing as vinegar and cold as ice. Ambition stripped of all pretense.

Touch of Evil

1958

US

Welles’ masterwork is a disconnected emotionally remote study of moral dissipation. Crisp b&w lensing by Russell Metty.

Odds Against Tomorrow

1959

US

A work of art from Rober Wise. New York City and its industrial fringe are quasi-protagonists that harbor the angst and desperation of life

outside the mainstream – sordid dreams of the last big heist that will fix everything.

Underworld USA

1961

US

Fast and furious pulp from Sam Fuller. Revenge finds redemption in death up a back alley the genesis of dark vengeance.
Requiem For A Heavyweight 1962

US

Rod Serling’s screenplay is lucid and economical. A washed-up boxer scenario in just under 82 minutes builds a closely realised character study, supported by a cast that delivers soulfully and with a leanness that is rarely matched.
The Pawnbroker 1964

US

The screenplay weaves the past and the present by juxtaposition and is economic when words are needed. Rod Steiger’s portrayal of Nazi death-camp survivor is a tour-de-force and his nominations for an Oscar and other accolades richly deserved.

A Colt is My Passport

1967

Japan

Aka ‘Koruto wa ore no pasupoto’. Hip acid Nikkatsu noir with surreal spaghetti-western score.
Klute 1971

US

Alan J. Pakula’s signature reworking of classic noir motifs in a masterly study of urban paranoia and alienation. Jane Fonda earned an Oscar for her brilliant portrayal of articulate b-girl the target of mystery psychopath.

4/4.5 star Noirs

Titles with an  * are reviewed on FilmsNoir.Net – list of reviews here .

All movies have a snap review .

La Chienne 1931 France
*City Streets 1931 US
*Fury 1936 US
*Guele d’Amour (aka Ladykiller) 1937 France
*Pépé le Moko 1937 France
La Bête Humaine 1938 France
*Blind Alley 1939 US
Le Jour se Lève 1939 France
*Macao,L’enfer Du Jeu (aka ‘Gambling Hell’) 1939 France
*Stranger on the 3rd Floor 1940 US
*Blues in the Night 1941 US
*High Sierra 1941 US
*The Face Behind the Mask 1941 US
*This Gun For Hire 1942 US
*The Fallen Sparrow 1943 US
*The Ghost Ship 1943 US
*Betrayed (aka ‘When Strangers Marry’) 1944 US
*Moontide 1944 US
*Phantom Lady 1944 US
The Mask of Dimitrios 1944 US
*The Woman in the Window 1944 US
*Cornered 1945 US
*Detour 1945 US
*Fallen Angel 1945 US
Leave Her to Heaven 1945 US
*My Name Is Julia Ross 1945 US
*Black Angel 1946 US
*Deadline at Dawn 1946 US
*Deception 1946 US
*Decoy 1946 US
*Gilda 1946 US
*High Wall 1946 US
*Night Editor 1946 US
Panique 1946 France
Suspense 1946 US
*The Blue Dahlia 1946 US
*The Chase 1946 US
*The Dark Corner 1946 US
*The Dark Mirror 1946 US
*The House on 92nd Street 1946 US
*Jigsaw 1946 US
*The Locket 1946 US
*The Strange Love of Martha Ivers 1946 US
*The Stranger 1946 US
*Born to Kill 1947 US
Brute Force 1947 US
*Dark Passage 1947 US
*Dark 1947 US
*Dead Reckoning 1947 US
*Desperate 1947 US
*Kiss of Death 1947 US
*The Devil Thumbs a Ride 1947 US
Odd Man Out 1947 US
*Railroaded 1947 US
*Shoot To Kill 1947 US
*The Long Night 1947 US
*The Unsuspected 1947 US
*The Woman On the Beach 1947 US
*They Made Me a Fugitive 1947 UK
*Secret Beyond the Door 1948 US
*Blood on the Moon 1948 US
*They Won’t Believe Me 1947 US
*Bob le Flambuer 1956 France
*Call Northside 777 1948 US
Cry of the City 1948 US
*I Love Trouble 1948 US
*I Walk Alone 1948 US
*Key Largo 1948 US
*Kiss the Blood Off My Hands 1948 US
*Moonrise 1948 US
*Night Has a Thousand Eyes 1948 US
*Pitfall 1948 US
*Road House 1948 US
*Ruthless 1948 US
Senza pietà (Aka Without Pity) 1948 Italy
*The Amazing Mr. X 1948 US
*The Big Clock 1948 US
*The Iron Curtain 1948 US
*The Naked City 1948 US
*A Woman’s Secret 1949 US
*Alias Nick Beal 1949 US
*Caught 1949 US
*Follow Me Quietly 1949 US
*I Married a Communist 1949 US
*The Big Steal 1949 US
*The Bribe 1949 US
*The Clay Pigeon 1949 US
*The Man Who Cheated Himself 1949 US
*Salón México 1949 Mexico
*The Window 1949 US
*Whirlpool 1949 US
*Armored Car Robbery 1950 US
*Gambling House 1950 US
*Gun Crazy 1950 US
*Manèges 1950 France
*No Man of Her Own 1950 US
*No Way Out 1950 US
*Panic In the Streets 1950 US
*Side Street 1950 US
*Tension 1950 US
*The File On Thelma Jordan 1950 US
*The Killer That Stalked New York 1950 US
*The Second Woman 1950 US
*The Tattooed Stranger 1950 US
*Union Station 1950 US
*Walk Softly, Stranger 1950 US
*Where Danger Lives 1950 US
*Where the Sidewalk Ends 1950 US
*Woman on the Run 1950 US
*Young Man with a Horn 1950 US
*Detective Story 1951 US
*He Ran All the Way 1951 US
His Kind of Woman 1951 US
*I Can Get It for You Wholesale 1951 US
*I was a Communist for the FBI 1951 US
*Roadblock 1951 US
*The Big Night 1951 US
*The Well 1951 US
*Tomorrow Is Another Day 1951 US
*Angel Face 1952 US
Kansas City Confidential 1952 US
*Scandal Sheet 1952 US
*The Narrow Margin 1952 US
*The Sniper 1952 US
*The Thief 1952 US
*99 River Street 1953 US
*Pickup On South Street 1953 US
Split Second 1953 US
*The Blue Gardenia 1953 US
*The Glass Wall 1953 US
*The Hitch-Hiker 1953 US
*Human Desire 1954 US
*Pushover 1954 US
*The Good Die Young 1954 UK
Touchez pas au Grisbi 1954 France
*Witness to Murder 1954 US
*The Burglar 1955 US
*World For Ransom 1955 US
Bob le Flambeur 1956 France
*The Phenix City Story 1955 US
*Patterns 1956 US
People of No Importance (aka ‘Gens san Importance’) 1956 France
*Ubiytsy (‘The Killers’) 1956 USSR
The Wrong Man 1956 US
*The Killing 1956 US
*Voici le temps des assassin (aka ‘Deadlier Than the Male’) 1956 France
While the City Sleeps 1956 US
*Elevator to the Gallows 1958 France
*Endless Desire 1958 Japan
*Tread Softly Stranger 1958 UK
Underworld Beauty (aka ‘Ankokugai no bijo’) 1958 Japan
*The Crimson Kimono 1959 US
The Bad Sleep Well (aka ‘Warui yatsu hodo yoku nemuru’) 1960 Japan
Shoot the Piano Player 1960 France
Blast of Silence 1961 US
*Le Doulos 1962 France
*High and Low (aka Tengoku to jigok) 1963 Japan
*The Naked Kiss 1964 US
*Memento 2000 US

43 Comments

  1. Todd T

    Wow, what an engaging and useful list! Especially like the pithy encapsulation. I have seen about 50 of your top 65 and will make an effort to see the others ASAP. Maybe bc I am a Mitchum fan, I think Angel Face is top tier, and I’m guessing for Night of the Hunter not to make your top 200, you don’t classify it as noir. I Wake Up Screaming should def be in your second tier, I think, for Laird Cregar’s performance alone, plus some good B&W photography. Great list!

  2. Thanks Todd! Great contribution.

  3. buzz daly

    great lists…i think dark corner, blue dahlia and crossfire belong on the first list…

  4. LaraP

    Amazing list. Wow. Just wow. THIS is brilliant stuff. I’ve bookmarked for future reference, as well. Your list and this list of the best film noir movies are now my go-to’s.

  5. Thanks Lara! Tony

  6. Shane Solow

    Superb list. A number of good films here I did not know about. If I might suggest a film not on your list …. I think “The Suspect” directed by Robert Siodmak with Charles Laughton is another excellent noir.

  7. Thanks Shane! The Suspect is ‘queued’ and you should see a review up here soon. Tony

  8. Charles Michener

    Great, great list. But where’s the greatest noir film since “Double Indemnity” – Polanski’s “Chinatown?”

  9. Charles two reasons. Firstly Polanski made a ‘genre’ movie that is a segue on noir not a film noir, and secondly I don’t consider it that great a film. I readily admit this is a minority view. Thanks. Tony

  10. Nick Dorgan

    Great list and great site! I look forward to watching them all. I notice a lack of Alfred Hitchcock, with the exception of “The Wrong Man”. Are you not a fan or do his other classics not qualify for the list?

  11. Thanks Nick. The list is not exhaustive as I add a movie only afer a recent viewing. I need to revisit the Hitchcock noirs such as The Wrong Man and Strangers on a Train.

  12. John Jay

    Fantastic list, I’ve been chipping away at it for a while now. A few thoughts:

    The Narrow Margin had so many errors in editing and the story (Charles McGraw completely forgets about Marie Windsor at the end…) that I feel it shouldn’t even be in the Second Tier.

    Conversely, Gun Crazy and The Naked City should be First Tier for certain. The photography and editing in Dassin’s classic are legendary and the lines the actors deliver offer exceptional social commentary.

    Gun Crazy just a great movie with great action, acting, and emotion. Peggy Cummins is very convincing in her role.

  13. Hey John. Thanks for your input.

    The Narrow Margin was butchered by the meddling of Howard Hughes, and contuinity does suffer, but overall it is solid and deserves recognition for the reasons I cover in my review: http://filmsnoir.net/film_noir/the-narrow-margin-1952-b-plus.html.

    My placements for Gun Crazy and The Naked City are I admit open to strong dispute. My reviews for each of the movies: http://filmsnoir.net/film_noir/gun-crazy-1950-not-so-bonnie-and-clyde.html, and http://filmsnoir.net/film_noir/the-naked-city-1948-there-are-8-million-stories.html, give some insight to my reasoning.

  14. cigar joe

    Check out The Enforcer (1951) it was off my radar. Directed by Bretaigne Windust (Raoul Walsh uncredited) written by Martin Rackin, an Ensemble Film Noir that stars a plethora of film noir alumni, Humphrey Bogart, Zero Mostel, Ted de Corsia, Everett Sloane, Roy Roberts, Don Beddoe, Jack Lambert, and other colorful character actors.

    I had never heard of it before and was pleasantly surprised. The story loosely based on Murder Inc. begins when Rico (Ted de Corsia) the main witness on a murder trial survives a sniper attack only to fall to his death accidentally the night before the trial. DA (Bogart) and his right hand man (Roy Roberts) fine comb the case records attempting to find some other clue against the defendant Mendoza (Everett Sloane). From this point on it’s one of the few noirs with the classic devise of a flashback inside of a flashback telling you how the police investigation was advanced to bust up Murder Inc.

  15. cigar joe

    P.S. (The Enforcer) Very moody cinematography throughout that compliments the story and cast, by Director of Photography Robert Burks (Tomorrow Is Another Day), who was known later for his collaborations with Hitchcock (North by Northwest, Vertigo, The Wrong Man, Rear Window, Strangers on a Train). 8/10

  16. Hay Ray. I did a capsule review back in 2010 and it is not here as I didn’t think it was that great… sorry :)

    The Enforcer (1951) Bogart as an activist DA pursues Murder Inc in a noirish police procedural. The first time the sinister usage of ‘contract’ was spoken on the screen. Bogart sadly just goes through the motions, but the motley crew of contract killers display a truly disturbing pathology.

  17. Lee

    Great, great lists, love the the terse analyses. Tremendous resource! Double Indemnity, out of the past, lady from shanghai, maltese falcon, big heat, sunset Blvd. & postman always rings twice are some of my faves. Need to see more of the films on these lists! A few comments, I fell Laura is vastly overrated, and Dark Passage should have made the 2nd tier at least. Enjoyable Bogey/Bacall vehicle. Film noir 4ever!

  18. Thanks Lee. Great to have your feedback. The unique scenario gives Laura a spot. Now that you mention it Dark Passage does merit a place in the supplementary list – I will update soonest. Tony

  19. Drew

    I’d like to echo everyone’s comments – great, helpful list and a valuable resource. I’m now using this as my film noir grocery list.

    Of course as a fellow lover of noir, I have my favorites that I think should have a spot on the list. The Lineup is a sharp, at times brutal noir that still managed to shock me. Murder by contract is a clever, quirky, and influential film with a cool score.

    Thanks for this, Tony – I plan to be a regular visitor to the site.

  20. Thanks Drew. Great to have you on board :)

    The list is fluid and and far from final. I still have a backlog of movies to watch or revisit, and the two you mention are on that list.

    Tony

  21. Lee

    Hey Tony, I just noticed there’s no Hitch on this list (unless I’m mistaken). Films like Shadow of a Doubt, Strangers on a Train, spellbound, and Notorious often are mentioned when Noir is discussed as some of the better examples. So far of those I’ve only seen “Strangers” as yet, and it didn’t really seem all that “noir” to me, though it had some elements. I think it is quite a good (but not great, IMO) film. If I were in charge of the lists I might have thrown it on the second tier, due to its historical significance, but I don’t disagree with its exclusion. So I’m just wondering: are you not such a great Hitchcock fan, or perhaps don’t think any of his films are noir, or are there other reasons for no Hitch films?

  22. Lee, I am not a fan of Hitchcock. Truth be told I find him cold and manipulative. I accept this is an eccentric position. Still no reason to exclude his movies. But yes, I really need to revisit his films from a noir perspective. Thanks for bringing this up. Sometimes I need to be kick-started :)

  23. William Gnoss

    Hi Tony:
    Thanks for all the research and effort you have put into this list, I am going to translate it to excel so I will be able to sort it for purposes of trying to find those films I have not yet seen or been able to acquire (altho there are a lot on You Tube). Surely, you can whittle the list down into your personal 15 favorites?

  24. Hi William. I am up to the challenge :) I will return here soonest with my personal top 20.

  25. Lee

    Yeah Tony I’d like to see your top-20 as well! I have started to formulate a list of my top films but as a Noir neophyte I need to see many, more before I could do a final list. I guess I could throw a preliminary top-10 out there: 1. Double Indemnity 2. Maltese Falcon 3.Sunset Blvd. 4. Out of the Past. 5. The Big heat 6. White Heat 7. Lady From Shanghai 8. Scarlet Street 9. Kiss Me Deadly. 10 Secret beyond the Door. But again, so many Noirs as yet unseen. I hope I can replace some of these with even better films!

  26. Guys, this is my top 25 in alphabetical order. Ranking them would be abitrary as there is little if anything between them.

    Act of Violence, 1948, US
    The Asphalt Jungle, 1950, US
    The Big Combo, 1955, US
    The Big Heat, 1953, US
    The Big Sleep, 1946, US
    Body and Soul, 1947, US
    Double Indemnity, 1944, US
    Force of Evil, 1948, US
    Kiss Me Deadly, 1955, US
    The Lady From Shanghai, 1947, US
    The Maltese Falcon, 1941, US
    Murder My Sweet, 1944, US
    Night And the City, 1950, US/UK
    Odds Against Tomorrow, 1959, US
    On Dangerous Ground, 1951, US
    Out of the Past, 1947, US
    Port of Shadows, 1938, France
    The Prowler, 1951, US
    The Set-Up, 1949, US
    Raw Deal, 1948, US
    Ride the Pink Horse, 1946, US
    Rififi, 1955, France
    Sweet Smell of Success, 1957, US
    The Third Man, 1949, UK
    T-Men, 1947, US

    Tony

  27. Lee

    Hey Tony, I am writing to lobby on behalf of Diabolique. Just saw this masterpiece. Oh wow!! It blew me away. I mean, this is why I watch films, to be completely in the moment. To have my eyes wide open, unable to blink, and my jaw on the floor. In addition to being a flat out masterpiece, to me it has the black heart of noir beating within, for sure. So just curious, why no placement in your lists? For my money, it belongs with the 5-star cornerstones of the genre.

  28. Hey Lee. Yes, my lists are light on French noirs of the 50s and 60s. The main reason is that I haven’t caught up with any recently, and I only add a movie to a list after re-watching it. Chabrol definitely deserves my attention.

  29. Alan

    I’m pleased Tony that you have chosen a top25 list . Top ten lists leaves little scope . 4 films on your list I haven’t viewed ,looking forward to checking them out . I notice that you omitted Touch of Evil and included The Lady from Shanghai . Many critics and bloggers singled out the incoherence of the narrative in the second half of the film . For a tampered (butchered flick ) it’s style and acting ,direction , is an artistic treat /marvel. A great resource website ,thank you .

  30. Thank you Alan. Much appreciated. Any list will be to some extent arbitrary and always idiosyncratic. Touch Of Evil is great and as worthy as those that made the list, but Lady From Shanghai is so tantalisingly close even in its butchered form to perfection that it holds for me a more vibrant attraction. It’s very weaknesses have you pondering the puzzle anew and in different ways with each re-viewing.

  31. Alan

    Hello Tony , a couple of thoughts on opinions you expressed . Firstly , Hitchcock , to me doesn’t come across as a ‘noir’ director as such .His scripts and direction tend to fall into the thriller/mystery genres , with at times strong influences of french/german noir . His penchant to engage his audience is voyeuristic , his love scenes are not of unihibited passion but an end of a paragraph awaiting the next scenario .In fact Hitch didn’t have that many and in Nth by NWest tunnel scene we were cleverly left in the dark. 2ndly ,Having recently viewed again Pepe le Moko ,Rififi, Touchez pas au Grisbi, I accept general opinion that these are noir styled and scipted films ( and great films to be viewed again ) but, the language of film – expression ,accent,slang ,local colloquialisms ,conversation that depicts an era ,words that are now out of common usage , are uniquely American in regards to film noir . I watched 2 nights ago on TV Kansas City Confidential , a good second tier film noir , all the ingredients , but above all fun to watch . What struck me is that German,French,Italian,Japanese even British noir feels as though it shouldn’t lie in the same bed as the American noir . That as a style / genre ,the Hollywood melting pot at that time condensed various genres to form an generally efficent producton line of many quality noir ‘B’ movies ,I’m not sure that this case in the countries mentioned . Being an Aussie I’m not being jingoistic in my opinion , more that , Americian noir is unique via language and represents film noir in it’s most pure form . I think in terms of European noir ,Asian noir . Mutch as J-Horror ,K- Horror as a contrast to American horror films same genre but ever so different .I’m interested to hear from you Tony ,I could be just dribbling out a pile of crap .

  32. Hi Alan. Thanks for your contribution, which is more than welcome.

    I agree on Hitchcock, though the consensus is against us. I find him manipulative and essentially misanthropic. Noir on the other hand is subversive – making us feel a certain empathy for the noir protagonist, who more often than not is caught in a web spun by fate.

    Fatalism to my thinking is an essential element, and this is the defining link from French poetic realism. Expressionism takes us back further to the silent era with a necessary nod to German cinema. In American film noir you have a disparate number of factors that ignited the flash of classic noir. The hard-boiled fiction of Hammett and Chandler and other early crime writers; the European diaspora of film-makers that made Hollywood their home in the 30s and 40s discerning the dark underbelly of the American dream; the relative creative freedom given to the makers of b-movies; and the burgeoning awareness of psychology in the early 40s.

    But yes, Hollywood noir has a distinctive American voice that is integral to its impact and appeal. Consider Double Indemnity. I cannot imagine the film without Chandler’s dialog.

  33. Alan

    Hello Tony , a good run of films on TV lately ,Gilda ,KS Confidential and Journey Into Fear. The latter, Cotton scripted film staring the Mercury team ,I was led to believe by many critics and commentators that this was a poor effort and not worth seeking out . Journey Into Fear was intriguing ,beautfully shot, noir A1. Wells was tremendous , his grand entrance ,powerful (at first I didn’t recognise him being unaware of the plot) . Real edge of your seat entertainment . Just goes to show ,don’t be put off by the pundits and risk missing out seeing real gems . Tony I later read your review and backgrounding of JIF which gives it’s due . It was the 69 minute version ,I look forward to the missing 10 minutes integrated with the US release .

  34. Alan, the ABC1 late night movies schedule is a treasure trove of b’s and noirs. They have licensed the full RKO library long-term. Re JIF, if you can, get hold of Ambler’s original novel. All the Ambler thrillers from the 30s and 40s are great.

  35. Alan

    Merry Christmas Tony . Much debate on whether films are ‘film noir ‘or not or borderline examples of the style/genre . I have no recall in my limited reading of a desciption or term to define these films as a matter of convience ( yes I know another box ) , but quite awhile ago I gave a dvd on loan to a friend , I used the term ‘ faux noir ‘ specifically Chinatown ,may as well keep it French .

  36. Thanks Alan. Best wishes for the festive season. I love the moniker ‘faux noir’ which I have never heard before. Very apt and nicely provocative. I certainly have issues with the application of the neo-noir label to a lot of movies that to my mind are too self-conscious about their noir-ness. Once a film-maker contrives to make a noir film the idea negates the ethos. Though there is a photo of Robert Aldrich on the set of Kiss Me Deadly (1955) holding a copy of the French edition of the first ever book about film noir, A Panorama of American Film Noir, 1941-1953, by Raymond Borde and Étienne Chaumeton published France in 1955, and only translated into English in 2000.

  37. Alan

    Thank you Tony for your v.interesting response . I’m intrigued by your comment ‘ once a film-maker contrives to make a noir film the idea negates the ethos ‘ . The directors of the 40’s and 50’s were to a degree mavericks both sides of the Atlantic , influencing each other and influenced by earlier films of directors still active in the industry ,or simply expermenting due to limited budgets a wonderful dark style . Camera angle ,focus and lighting . B films directed by legends of film such as Lang in Hollywood . It’s like punk and new wave music of the 70’s and early 80’s ,a window of opportunity within an undetermined time frame and changing taste ,it too was initially instigated by mavericks and on shoestring budgets . Tony , your comment reminds me of early Coen Bros films ,LA Confidendtial etc, by their paying homage , consciously to the classic noir themes , this in itself is a distraction and quite often result in failure such as De Palma’s Black Dahlia trying too hard to be noir with an incoherent script guising as ‘mystery’ , like ‘lite’ beer ,I prefer the original .

  38. Yes Allan. I prefer my bourbon straight ;)

  39. Lee

    Hey Tony, I’m wondering what your take is on western “noirs”. I recently watched Pursued, pretty enjoyable film with many noir elements, yet the urban settings and yes even trenchcoats seem so essential to the noir aesthetic. So for you is the western noir a valid subgenre? Why or why not?

  40. Hi Lee. I am with you here. It is a stretch to talk about noir westerns. Blood on The Moon comes pretty close, and apart from Pursued, I don’t see there are any others. And when speaking of these two I would say they are Westerns with noir elements.

    Noir is essentially concerned with the modern metropolis and the alienation that characterizes the noir protaganist – a flanuer whose existence paradoxically mirrors the anonymity of city life “in a lonely place” amongst the teeming masses. Even a so-called rural noir like On Dangerous Ground has as its dynamic the brutalized cop from the city.

  41. Lee

    Cheers Tony. “Westerns with Noir elements” – I completely agree. It is a fun subgenre to be sure, but they are Westerns first and foremost. I could picture scene for scene the entire fatalistic plot of Pursued being played out in a shadowy noir milieu, but it is still a western first and foremost. Still it is fun to seek out such films, someone on back alley noir made the apt comment “for those who have “seen it all” in classic noir, that these post-war Westerns offer an intriguing, rewarding filmic vein”. I’ve got Ramrod to watch that has shown up on some “Western Noir” lists and Blood on the Moon that you mentioned is another. Station West, The Devil’s Doorway, The Furies, and Yellow Sky have also been mentioned and I intend to check those all out eventually.

  42. Dan P.

    Thank you for all the work put into your list. Sure, there are some I feel should be included (Strangers on a Train, as mentioned), but you have given me hours of fine entertainment with films I have missed.

    Thank you again!

  43. Thanks Dan. Great to know that you have found the list useful. Sorry your comment was in moderation for so long, I didn’t get the usual email alerts of new comments after a WordPress glitch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>